Comparative Genomics of Flowering Time Pathways Using Brachypodium distachyon as a Model for the Temperate Grasses

Arrows show promoting effects, T-bars show repressing effects. Environmental cues are shown as lower case letters in square boxes; v is extended cold (vernalization); ld is long days; sd is short days; am is ambient (non-vernalizing) temperature. Genes are shown in italics and proteins in non-italics in ovals. Proteins are clearly involved at all stages but we make this distinction only in cases where separate controls are known to exist for transcription and protein function or stability. # indicates inhibition of protein function. The pathways were compiled from the following reviews , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , plus individual articles referenced in the text. Box A. In Arabidopsis genes assigned to pathways are shown in colour (photoperiod pathway in green, vernalization pathway in blue, autonomous pathway in light blue). Flowering pathway integrators are shown in red. Triple headed arrows indicate activation by red or blue light. Box B. Rice genes identified as homologues of those in Arabidopsis are shown in black. Ambiguous homology is indicated with a question mark. Genes with published roles in photoperiod regulated flowering are shown in green and orthologues of pathway integrators in red. Box C. In the temperate grasses box Brachypodium genes identified as homologues of those of Arabidopsis or rice are shown in black. The VRN2 and CO3 genes from barley and wheat are also included. Genes with published roles in photoperiod or vernalization regulated flowering in barley or wheat are shown in green or blue, respectively, and orthologues of pathway integrators in red. In B and C likely orthologues of Arabidopsis genes are shown in equivalent positions within the figure (e.g. Hd1 is the rice orthologue of CO and Hd3a and RFT1 are rice orthologues of FT). and gives information on gene names and synonyms. Square brackets in box B show three maize genes with known flowering time effects. Notes: *1 TOC1 represses PRR9, PRR7 and PRR5 . *2 SUF4 interacts with FRI and FRL1. LD blocks SUF4 action to reduce FLC expression . *3 Cerdan and Chory identified PFT1 and proposed that it promotes flowering by a photoperiod independent pathway activating FT. The model here follows Wollenberg et al. who propose an alternative in which PFT1 acts by repressing Pfr phytochrome signalling. *4 SWR1 is a protein complex including SWC6, ARP6 and PIE1. *5 CO expression from phloem-specific promoters complements the co mutation, but expression from meristem-specific promoters does not. CO triggers flowering from the phloem by the cell-autonomous activation of FT expression . *6 High temperatures (27°C vs 23°C) in short days induce flowering by a mechanism that requires FT and gibberellic acid and likely involves MAF1 (FLM). High temperature induction of flowering is independent of the photoperiod pathway but is repressed by FLC and by autonomous pathway mutations that increase FLC levels . Kumar and Wigge showed that ambient temperature responses, including the activation of FT, involve the replacement of histone H2A.Z with H2A in nucleosomes. Mutation of ARP6 (part of the SWR1 complex) blocks this process. The late-flowering phenotype of dominant fwa mutants is caused by hypomethylation in the FWA locus leading to ectopic expression of a homeodomain leucine zipper (HD-ZIP) protein. The FWA protein interacts with FT protein and so ectopic expression of FWA delays flowering by impairing FT function . FWA is not expressed during the vegetative phase in wild type plants and normally has no role in flowering so homologues are not considered in this paper. *7 TWIN SISTER OF FT (TSF) is closely related to FT, is activated by CO, has a similar role in flowering and is repressed by SVP (; reviewed by , ). *8 Activation of AP1 and LFY requires two paralogous homeobox genes (PENNYWISE (PNY; aka BELLRINGER and REPLUMLESS) and POUND-FOOLISH (PNF)). Double null mutants express SOC1 and FUL but not AP1 or LFY. The double mutants can receive floral inductive signals but do not properly restructure the shoot apical meristem to make flowers , . *9 GI promotion of Hd1/CO is shown directly but could act through the FKF1/CDF route as in Arabidopsis. *10 Mayfield et al. found that 14-3-3 proteins physically interact with CO in Arabidopsis. *11 It is unclear if there is a direct connection between OsMADS50 and OsMADS14/15 as well as the connection via Edh1. *12 Ppd-H1 promotion of CO is shown directly but could act through the FKF1/CDF route as in Arabidopsis. *13 Downregulation of VRT2 by vernalization and a role in repressing VRN1 is proposed by Kane et al. , but is not supported by Trevaskis et al. so VRT2 is shown in two positions. *14 Shitsukawa et al. found that WSOC1 was expressed preferentially in leaves. Expression was not affected by photoperiod or vernalization but was upregulated in seedlings by a GA treatment. *15 X indicates an unknown target gene . Key to figures of phylogenetic trees A PRANK alignment of protein sequences (shown in the supplementary datasets) was used to construct phylogenetic trees using the neighbor-joining algorithm (subsequently NJ trees) with bootstrap support from 1000 iterations (values of ≥50% shown). Gene identifiers show the species as follows: At for Arabidopsis thaliana, Bradi for Brachypodium distachyon, Os for Orzya sativa (rice), Hv for Hordeum vulgare (barley), Ta for Triticum aestivum (bread wheat), Tm for Triticum monococcum (einkorn wheat), Sb for Sorghum bicolour (sorghum) and Zm for Zea mays (maize). Barley and wheat proteins are highly homologous and usually only one is shown. Gene names follow the identifiers where relevant to the text and genes with known flowering time roles are shown in colour following . In several instances we identified pairs of genes in grasses (paralogues) in segmental duplications (SegDup) which likely result from a grass whole genome duplication that predates the divergence of the rice, maize, sorghum, Brachypodium, barley and wheat lineages. These duplication events are shown as solid circles. Similarly, solid diamonds showduplication events in Arabidopsis; these are independent from the duplication event in the grasses. Boxed T shows tandem or closely arranged paralogues resulting from duplications within individual species. Where the protein belongs to a large family we show small clades containing genes of interest selected from analyses of whole families. The clades were identified either by using an online interrogatory tree of the transcription factor family using known flowering-time genes as query sequences or from the family trees shown in the supplementary material. Key to figures of segmental duplications In these figures the size and spacing of genes in the respective genomic sequences is shown to the physical scale indicated in each figure. The components of each half of the duplication are grouped under the bars at the top of the figure. For example, shows part of rice chromosome 3 which is colinear with part of Brachypodium chromosome 1 and is related to part of rice chromosome 7 by segmental duplication. This section of rice 7 is colinear with a separate section of Brachypodium 1. Identifiers and names of flowering-time genes and their homologues are shown, with colours following . Gene identifiers are also shown at the top and bottom of each segment to allow orientation to the respective genome browsers. The segmental duplications are recognized by conserved genes (black boxes connected by black lines). Some figures have grey boxes which show genes that are not conserved across the duplication in all species. Within these regions, other genes are conserved between species but not across the duplication (red boxes connected by red lines). These are deletion/insertion events that occurred after the duplication arose but before the divergence of the respective species. Genes in yellow are not conserved across species and represent candidates for deletion/insertion events that occurred after species divergence. Hypothetical genes and sequences annotated as transposons are excluded. In most cases the segmental duplications extend further than shown as we only use those portions that are relevant to the relationships of the flowering-time genes discussed in the text.
Comparative Genomics of Flowering Time Pathways Using Brachypodium distachyon as a Model for the Temperate Grasses

Publication

Comparative Genomics of Flowering Time Pathways Using Brachypodium distachyon as a Model for the Temperate Grasses. (2010) Janet A. Higgins, et al. PLoS One. 2010;5(4):e10065. Figure: F1.

Gene mentions


Organism Group Word Match Source NCBI Symbol NCBI ID
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi PRR7 PRR7 ncbigene_symbol PRR7 831793
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi PRR9- PRR9 ncbigene_symbol PRR9 819292
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi PRR5- PRR5 ncbigene_symbol PRR5 832518
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi (Hd2) HD2 ncbigene_synonym HD2B 832328
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi (Ppd1) PPD1 ncbigene_symbol PPD1 827123
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi (Ppd1) PPD1 ncbigene_symbol PPD1 827223
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi LHY LHY ncbigene_symbol LHY 839341
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi CCA1 CCA1 ncbigene_symbol CCA1 819296
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi ELF4 ELF4 ncbigene_symbol ELF4 818596
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi ZTL ZTL ncbigene_symbol ZTL 835842
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi PRR3- PRR3 ncbigene_symbol PRR3 836132
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi GI GI ncbigene_symbol GI 838883
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FVE FVE ncbigene_symbol FVE 816471
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FPA FPA ncbigene_symbol FPA 818942
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FLK FLK ncbigene_symbol FLK 819619
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi LD LD ncbigene_symbol LD 827904
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FLD FLD ncbigene_symbol FLD 820202
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FY FY ncbigene_symbol FY 831191
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FCA FCA ncbigene_symbol FCA 827323
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi LUX LUX ncbigene_synonym PCL1 823817
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi CLF CLF ncbigene_symbol CLF 816870
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FIE1 FIE1 ncbigene_synonym FIE 821622
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi MSI1 MSI1 ncbigene_symbol MSI1 835935
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi SWN SWN ncbigene_symbol SWN 828165
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi VEL1 VEL1 ncbigene_symbol VEL1 829143
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi CHE CHE ncbigene_synonym TCP11 830730
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi VRN5 VRN5 ncbigene_symbol VRN5 822034
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi TOC1 TOC1 ncbigene_symbol TOC1 836259
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi CRY1 CRY1 ncbigene_symbol CRY1 826470
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi VIN3 VIN3 ncbigene_symbol VIN3 835844
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi VRN1 VRN1 ncbigene_symbol VRN1 821432
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi VRN2 VRN2 ncbigene_symbol VRN2 827392
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi COP1 COP1 ncbigene_symbol COP1 817857
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi ELF3 ELF3 ncbigene_symbol ELF3 817134
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi CRY2 CRY2 ncbigene_symbol CRY2 839529
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FKF1 FKF1 ncbigene_symbol FKF1 843133
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi LKP2 LKP2 ncbigene_symbol LKP2 816408
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi CDF1 CDF1 ncbigene_symbol CDF1 832368
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi CDF1 CDF1 ncbigene_symbol CDF1 836364
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FRI FRI ncbigene_symbol FRI 828044
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FRL1 FRL1 ncbigene_symbol FRL1 831493
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FRL1 FRL1 ncbigene_synonym SMT2 838621
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FRL2 FRL2 ncbigene_symbol FRL2 840070
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FES1 FES1 ncbigene_symbol FES1 817951
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi CDF2 CDF2 ncbigene_symbol CDF2 833962
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi COL9 COL9 ncbigene_symbol COL9 819956
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi CDF3 CDF3 ncbigene_symbol CDF3 823904
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi CDF3 CDF3 ncbigene_synonym LTP2 818435
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi SUF4 SUF4 ncbigene_symbol SUF4 839984
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi EFS? EFS ncbigene_symbol EFS 844066
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi miR172 MIR172 ncbigene_synonym MIR172b 3770659
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi miR172 MIR172 ncbigene_synonym MIR172a 28718310
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi Hd1 HD1 ncbigene_symbol HD1 829969
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi AGL41 AGL41 ncbigene_symbol AGL41 817229
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi PHYB PHYB ncbigene_symbol PHYB 816394
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi SPA1 SPA1 ncbigene_symbol SPA1 819242
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi SPA3 SPA3 ncbigene_symbol SPA3 820767
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi SPA4 SPA4 ncbigene_symbol SPA4 841743
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi PEP PEP ncbigene_symbol PEP 828706
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi PEP PEP ncbigene_synonym PAS2 830912
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi HUA2 HUA2 ncbigene_symbol HUA2 832379
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FLC FLC ncbigene_symbol FLC 830878
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi LHP1 LHP1 ncbigene_synonym TFL2 831635
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi SMZ SMZ ncbigene_symbol SMZ 824664
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi TOE1? TOE1 ncbigene_synonym RAP2.7 817403
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi PHYA PHYA ncbigene_symbol PHYA 837483
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi MAF1 MAF1 ncbigene_symbol MAF1 844042
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi TEM1 TEM1 ncbigene_symbol TEM1 839143
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi TEM2 TEM2 ncbigene_synonym RAV2 843216
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi НАР5, HAP5 ncbigene_synonym CCC1 839924
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi Ehd1 EHD1 ncbigene_symbol EHD1 821573
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi AGL19 AGL19 ncbigene_symbol AGL19 828394
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi AGL24 AGL24 ncbigene_symbol AGL24 828556
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi CIB1 CIB1 ncbigene_symbol CIB1 829604
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi SVP SVP ncbigene_symbol SVP 816787
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi SOC1 SOC1 ncbigene_synonym AGL20 819174
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FT FT ncbigene_symbol FT 842859
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FD FD ncbigene_symbol FD 829744
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FT1 FT1 ncbigene_symbol FT1 814851
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi ELF9 ELF9 ncbigene_symbol ELF9 831486
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi SPL3 SPL3 ncbigene_symbol SPL3 817948
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi FUL FUL ncbigene_synonym AGL8 836212
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi AGL17 AGL17 ncbigene_symbol AGL17 816794
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi AP1 AP1 ncbigene_symbol AP1 843244
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi TFL1 TFL1 ncbigene_symbol TFL1 831683
Arabidopsis thaliana Plants and Fungi LFY LFY ncbigene_symbol LFY 836307
Homo sapiens Primates Temp TEMP ncbigene_synonym C1orf210 149466
Homo sapiens Primates PRR7 PRR7 ncbigene_symbol PRR7 80758
Homo sapiens Primates PRR9- PRR9 ncbigene_symbol PRR9 574414
Homo sapiens Primates PRR5- PRR5 ncbigene_symbol PRR5 55615
Homo sapiens Primates (Hd2) HD2 ncbigene_synonym HDAC2 3066
Homo sapiens Primates (Hd2) HD2 ncbigene_synonym DLL4 54567
Homo sapiens Primates (Ppd1) PPD1 ncbigene_synonym GLI1 2735
Homo sapiens Primates CCA1 CCA1 ncbigene_symbol CCA1 878
Homo sapiens Primates CCA1 CCA1 ncbigene_synonym TRNT1 51095
Homo sapiens Primates ELF4 ELF4 ncbigene_symbol ELF4 2000
Homo sapiens Primates PRR3- PRR3 ncbigene_symbol PRR3 80742
Homo sapiens Primates PRR3- PRR3 ncbigene_synonym NECTIN3 25945
Homo sapiens Primates GI GI famplex_relations GNAO1 2775
Homo sapiens Primates GI GI famplex_relations GNAI1 2770
Homo sapiens Primates GI GI famplex_relations GNAI2 2771
Homo sapiens Primates GI GI famplex_relations GNAI3 2773
Homo sapiens Primates GI GI famplex_relations GNAT1 2779
Homo sapiens Primates GI GI famplex_relations GNAT2 2780
Homo sapiens Primates GI GI famplex_relations GNAT3 346562
Homo sapiens Primates GI GI famplex_relations GNAZ 2781
Homo sapiens Primates CLF CLF ncbigene_synonym CRLF1 9244
Homo sapiens Primates CLF CLF ncbigene_synonym CRNKL1 51340
Homo sapiens Primates CLF CLF ncbigene_synonym CLQTL1 54501
Homo sapiens Primates MSI1 MSI1 ncbigene_symbol MSI1 4440
Homo sapiens Primates Hd6 HD6 ncbigene_synonym ACKR2 1238
Homo sapiens Primates Hd6 HD6 ncbigene_synonym DEFA6 1671
Homo sapiens Primates Hd6 HD6 ncbigene_synonym HDAC6 10013
Homo sapiens Primates (VIL VIL ncbigene_synonym VIL1 7429
Homo sapiens Primates CRY1 CRY1 ncbigene_symbol CRY1 1407
Homo sapiens Primates COP1 COP1 ncbigene_symbol COP1 64326
Homo sapiens Primates COP1 COP1 ncbigene_synonym CARD16 114769
Homo sapiens Primates ELF3 ELF3 ncbigene_symbol ELF3 1999
Homo sapiens Primates CRY2 CRY2 ncbigene_symbol CRY2 1408
Homo sapiens Primates FRL2 FRL2 ncbigene_synonym FMNL3 91010
Homo sapiens Primates FES1 FES1 ncbigene_synonym HSPBP1 23640
Homo sapiens Primates PAF PAF ncbigene_synonym PCLAF 9768
Homo sapiens Primates EFS? EFS ncbigene_symbol EFS 10278
Homo sapiens Primates Hd1 HD1 ncbigene_synonym HDAC1 3065
Homo sapiens Primates Hd1 HD1 ncbigene_synonym PLEC 5339
Homo sapiens Primates ID1 ID1 ncbigene_symbol ID1 3397
Homo sapiens Primates SPA1 SPA1 ncbigene_synonym SIPA1 6494
Homo sapiens Primates SPA1 SPA1 ncbigene_synonym SFTPA1 653509
Homo sapiens Primates SPA SPA ncbigene_synonym CD5L 922
Homo sapiens Primates SPA SPA ncbigene_synonym SFTPA2 729238
Homo sapiens Primates PEP PEP ncbigene_synonym PAEP 5047
Homo sapiens Primates PEP PEP ncbigene_synonym PREP 5550
Homo sapiens Primates PEP PEP ncbigene_synonym PTPN22 26191
Homo sapiens Primates LHP1 LHP1 ncbigene_synonym LARP1 23367
Homo sapiens Primates TOE1? TOE1 ncbigene_symbol TOE1 114034
Homo sapiens Primates SIR2 SIR2 ncbigene_synonym SIRT2 22933
Homo sapiens Primates SIR2 SIR2 ncbigene_synonym SIRT1 23411
Homo sapiens Primates MAF1 MAF1 ncbigene_symbol MAF1 84232
Homo sapiens Primates TEM1 TEM1 ncbigene_synonym CD248 57124
Homo sapiens Primates TEM2 TEM2 ncbigene_synonym RASD2 23551
Homo sapiens Primates НАР5, HAP5 ncbigene_synonym NFYC 4802
Homo sapiens Primates Ehd1 EHD1 ncbigene_symbol EHD1 10938
Homo sapiens Primates AGL AGL ncbigene_symbol AGL 178
Homo sapiens Primates CIB1 CIB1 ncbigene_symbol CIB1 10519
Homo sapiens Primates lam LAM ncbigene_synonym TSC1 7248
Homo sapiens Primates lam LAM ncbigene_synonym TSC2 7249
Homo sapiens Primates SWR1) SWR1 ncbigene_synonym SRCAP 10847
Homo sapiens Primates FT1 FT1 ncbigene_synonym AKTIP 64400
Homo sapiens Primates RFT1 RFT1 ncbigene_symbol RFT1 91869
Homo sapiens Primates RFT1 RFT1 ncbigene_synonym SLC19A1 6573
Homo sapiens Primates RFT1 RFT1 ncbigene_synonym SLC52A1 55065
Homo sapiens Primates AP1 AP1 ncbigene_synonym FOS 2353
Homo sapiens Primates AP1 AP1 ncbigene_synonym FOSB 2354
Homo sapiens Primates AP1 AP1 ncbigene_synonym JUN 3725
Homo sapiens Primates AP1 AP1 ncbigene_synonym JUNB 3726
Homo sapiens Primates AP1 AP1 ncbigene_synonym JUND 3727
Homo sapiens Primates AP1 AP1 famplex_relations FOSL1 8061
Homo sapiens Primates AP1 AP1 famplex_relations FOSL2 2355
Homo sapiens Primates APEX APEX ncbigene_synonym APEX1 328
Zea mays Plants and Fungi FIE1 FIE1 ncbigene_synonym LOC542075 542075
Zea mays Plants and Fungi Hd6 HD6 ncbigene_synonym LOC541825 541825
Zea mays Plants and Fungi ID1 ID1 ncbigene_synonym LOC541693 541693
Zea mays Plants and Fungi PEP PEP ncbigene_synonym LOC542393 542393
Zea mays Plants and Fungi MAF1 MAF1 ncbigene_synonym LOC541767 541767
Zea mays Plants and Fungi BM1 BM1 ncbigene_synonym LOC542663 542663
Zea mays Plants and Fungi SOC1 SOC1 ncbigene_synonym LOC542042 542042
Zea mays Plants and Fungi AP1 AP1 ncbigene_synonym LOC542464 542464
Triticum aestivum Plants and Fungi FCA FCA ncbigene_synonym LOC543096 543096
Triticum aestivum Plants and Fungi VRN1 VRN1 ncbigene_synonym LOC543103 543103
Triticum aestivum Plants and Fungi VRN1 VRN1 ncbigene_synonym LOC543351 543351
Triticum aestivum Plants and Fungi SPA SPA ncbigene_synonym LOC543320 543320
Triticum aestivum Plants and Fungi MAF1 MAF1 ncbigene_synonym LOC542840 542840
Triticum aestivum Plants and Fungi SVP SVP ncbigene_synonym LOC780635 780635
Triticum aestivum Plants and Fungi Hd3a HD3A ncbigene_synonym LOC543392 543392
Triticum aestivum Plants and Fungi AGL17 AGL17 ncbigene_synonym LOC780649 780649

Chemical mentions

Word Match MeSH Name ChEBI

Disease mentions

Word Match MeSH Name DOID