(B) The bow-tie architecture also exists at the signal transduction level
(B) The bow-tie architecture also exists at the signal transduction level. There are bow-tie structures in the TLR signaling network and adaptive immunity where antigen presenting and recognition is the hub of the network. APCs express a diverse range of receptors to recognize a wide variety of pathogens via PAMPs, etc. Signaling pathways and capturing processes converge into a smaller variety of core processes. For TLRs, only a handful of adaptor proteins and kinases mediate the signaling process that results in diverse responses including cytokine release, transcription, and other events. The innate immune system comprises TLRs and their downstream cascades that form the characteristic shape of the network called a bow-tie, or hour-glass, structure (; ). A wide variety of pathogens and their molecules are represented by much smaller numbers of ligands, called PAMPs, recognized by IL-1R and 10 TLRs (; ). Only a handful of adaptor proteins, such as MyD88, MAL/TIRAP, TRIF, and TRAM, and two primary kinases (TBK1 and IRAK) mediate various responses and trigger massive changes in a broad range of transcription of target genes including secretion of cytokines and chemokines (). MyD88 has special importance as it constitutes a non-redundant core element of the main bow-tie network. Although there are collateral pathways such as MyD88-independent pathway, MyD88 is largely responsible for activation of TLR-mediated responses. Collateral pathways play roles in modulating different responses. This is a versatile architecture that enables organisms to evolutionarily add a new kind of receptor for new molecular signatures that eventually activate TBK1 and IRAK to bring about some responses. This is a bow-tie architecture at the signaling pathway, and exists in a broad range of somatic cells, but most saliently in macrophage and DC. In this bow-tie structure, there are nested bow-tie structures as well as positive feedback loops. For example, NF-κB and TNF form bow-tie structures having extensive input signals and changes in transcription and cytokine production (). Positive feedback loops involving NF-κB play an important role in the dynamics of the immune system in boosting innate immune response. An antigen-processing and presentation process captures a variety of peptides and presents them on MHC-I or MHC-II molecules that are recognized by TCRs. This antigen presentation and recognition part is a critical core process in adaptive immunity. A breach in proper presentation and recognition leads to improper immune reactions such as autoimmune diseases. Details of TLR signaling network are reported elsewhere (K Oda and H Kitano, in preparation).
Publication
Robustness trade-offs and host–microbial symbiosis in the immune system. (2006)
Hiroaki Kitano, et al. Mol Syst Biol. 2006;2:2006.0022-2006.0022. Figure: F1b.
All organisms
Mus musculus
Homo sapiens
Danio rerio
Organism
Group
Word
Match
Source
NCBI Symbol
NCBI ID
Mus musculus
Rodents
Hsp70
HSP70
ncbigene_synonym
Hspa1b
15511
Mus musculus
Rodents
Hsp60
HSP60
ncbigene_synonym
Hspd1
15510
Mus musculus
Rodents
LPS
LPS
ncbigene_synonym
Tlr4
21898
Mus musculus
Rodents
LTA.
LTA
ncbigene_symbol
Lta
16992
Mus musculus
Rodents
TLR2,
TLR2
ncbigene_symbol
Tlr2
24088
Mus musculus
Rodents
TLR3,
TLR3
ncbigene_symbol
Tlr3
142980
Mus musculus
Rodents
TLR7,
TLR7
ncbigene_symbol
Tlr7
170743
Mus musculus
Rodents
APCS
APCS
ncbigene_symbol
Apcs
20219
Mus musculus
Rodents
TNFR.
TNFR
ncbigene_synonym
Tnfrsf1a
21937
Mus musculus
Rodents
TIRAP
TIRAP
ncbigene_symbol
Tirap
117149
Mus musculus
Rodents
MOD2
MOD2
ncbigene_symbol
Mod2
110357
Mus musculus
Rodents
MOD2
MOD2
ncbigene_synonym
Cbx2
12416
Mus musculus
Rodents
MyD88
MYD88
ncbigene_symbol
Myd88
17874
Mus musculus
Rodents
IRAK
IRAK
ncbigene_synonym
Irak1
16179
Mus musculus
Rodents
Croвs-
CROS
ncbigene_synonym
Ros1
19886
Mus musculus
Rodents
AP-1
AP-1
ncbigene_synonym
Jun
16476
Mus musculus
Rodents
IRF3
IRF3
ncbigene_symbol
Irf3
54131
Mus musculus
Rodents
IL6
IL6
ncbigene_symbol
Il6
16193
Mus musculus
Rodents
IFN-a
IFNA
ncbigene_symbol
Ifna
111654
Mus musculus
Rodents
IL-1
IL-1
ncbigene_synonym
Il1
111343
Mus musculus
Rodents
TNF
TNF
ncbigene_symbol
Tnf
21926
Mus musculus
Rodents
NOS
NOS
ncbigene_synonym
Nos1
18125
Mus musculus
Rodents
IL-10
IL-10
ncbigene_synonym
Il10
16153
Mus musculus
Rodents
IL-4
IL-4
ncbigene_synonym
Il4
16189
Mus musculus
Rodents
NKT,
NKT
ncbigene_synonym
Ctsl
13039
Mus musculus
Rodents
NKT,
NKT
ncbigene_synonym
Slc22a6
18399
Mus musculus
Rodents
mast
MAST
ncbigene_synonym
Spg21
27965
Mus musculus
Rodents
mast
MAST
ncbigene_synonym
Spaca9
69987
Mus musculus
Rodents
CD4
CD4
ncbigene_symbol
Cd4
12504
Mus musculus
Rodents
T-cel
TCE1
ncbigene_synonym
Spsb3
79043
Mus musculus
Rodents
CD6+
CD6
ncbigene_symbol
Cd6
12511
Mus musculus
Rodents
STAT1
STAT1
ncbigene_symbol
Stat1
20846
Mus musculus
Rodents
STAT4
STAT4
ncbigene_symbol
Stat4
20849
Mus musculus
Rodents
STAT6
STAT6
ncbigene_symbol
Stat6
20852
Mus musculus
Rodents
GATA3
GATA3
ncbigene_symbol
Gata3
14462
Mus musculus
Rodents
C-MAF
C-MAF
ncbigene_synonym
Maf
17132
Mus musculus
Rodents
T-bet)
TBET
ncbigene_synonym
Tbx21
57765
Mus musculus
Rodents
NF-KB
NF-KB
ncbigene_synonym
Nfkb1
18033
Mus musculus
Rodents
Th
TH
ncbigene_symbol
Th
21823
Mus musculus
Rodents
IL-5||IL-10
IL-5
ncbigene_synonym
Il5
16191
Mus musculus
Rodents
IL-2|IL-13IL-4IL-5||IL-10
IL-2
ncbigene_synonym
Il2
16183
Mus musculus
Rodents
IL-13
IL-13
ncbigene_synonym
Il13
16163
Mus musculus
Rodents
CD25+
CD25
ncbigene_synonym
Il2ra
16184
Mus musculus
Rodents
TOR
TOR
ncbigene_symbol
tor
21977
Mus musculus
Rodents
TOR
TOR
ncbigene_synonym
Rorc
19885
Mus musculus
Rodents
pin
PIN
ncbigene_synonym
Dynll1
56455
Homo sapiens
Primates
Hsp70
HSP70
ncbigene_synonym
HSPA1A
3303
Homo sapiens
Primates
Hsp70
HSP70
ncbigene_synonym
HSPA4
3308
Homo sapiens
Primates
Hsp60
HSP60
ncbigene_synonym
HSPD1
3329
Homo sapiens
Primates
LPS
LPS
ncbigene_synonym
IRF6
3664
Homo sapiens
Primates
LTA.
LTA
ncbigene_symbol
LTA
4049
Homo sapiens
Primates
TLR2,
TLR2
ncbigene_symbol
TLR2
7097
Homo sapiens
Primates
TLR3,
TLR3
ncbigene_symbol
TLR3
7098
Homo sapiens
Primates
TLR4,
TLR4
ncbigene_symbol
TLR4
7099
Homo sapiens
Primates
L-IR
LIR
ncbigene_synonym
CD300C
10871
Homo sapiens
Primates
TLR7,
TLR7
ncbigene_symbol
TLR7
51284
Homo sapiens
Primates
APCS
APCS
ncbigene_symbol
APCS
325
Homo sapiens
Primates
TNFR.
TNFR
ncbigene_synonym
TNFRSF1A
7132
Homo sapiens
Primates
TIRAP
TIRAP
ncbigene_symbol
TIRAP
114609
Homo sapiens
Primates
MyD88
MYD88
ncbigene_symbol
MYD88
4615
Homo sapiens
Primates
IRAK
IRAK
ncbigene_synonym
IRAK1
3654
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMA1
5682
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMA2
5683
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMA3
5684
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMA4
5685
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMA5
5686
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMA6
5687
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMA7
5688
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMA8
143471
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMB1
5689
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMB10
5699
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMB2
5690
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMB3
5691
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMB4
5692
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMB5
5693
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMB6
5694
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMB7
5695
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMB8
5696
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMB9
5698
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMC1
5700
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMC2
5701
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMC3
5702
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMC4
5704
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMC5
5705
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMC6
5706
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMD1
5707
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMD10
5716
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMD11
5717
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMD12
5718
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMD13
5719
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMD14
10213
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMD2
5708
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMD3
5709
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMD4
5710
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMD5
5711
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMD6
9861
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMD7
5713
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMD8
5714
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMD9
5715
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSME1
5720
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSME2
5721
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSME3
10197
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
PSMF1
9491
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
SEM1
7979
Homo sapiens
Primates
proteasome
PROTEASOME
famplex_relations
USP5
8078
Homo sapiens
Primates
AP-1
AP-1
ncbigene_synonym
FOS
2353
Homo sapiens
Primates
AP-1
AP-1
ncbigene_synonym
FOSB
2354
Homo sapiens
Primates
AP-1
AP-1
ncbigene_synonym
JUN
3725
Homo sapiens
Primates
AP-1
AP-1
ncbigene_synonym
JUNB
3726
Homo sapiens
Primates
AP-1
AP-1
ncbigene_synonym
JUND
3727
Homo sapiens
Primates
IRF3
IRF3
ncbigene_symbol
IRF3
3661
Homo sapiens
Primates
IL-12
IL12
famplex_relations
IL12A
3592
Homo sapiens
Primates
IL-12
IL12
famplex_relations
IL12B
3593
Homo sapiens
Primates
IL6
IL6
ncbigene_symbol
IL6
3569
Homo sapiens
Primates
IFN-a
IFN-A
ncbigene_synonym
IFNA1
3439
Homo sapiens
Primates
IL-1
IL-1
ncbigene_synonym
IL1B
3553
Homo sapiens
Primates
TNF
TNF
ncbigene_symbol
TNF
7124
Homo sapiens
Primates
NOS
NOS
ncbigene_synonym
NOS1
4842
Homo sapiens
Primates
NOS
NOS
ncbigene_synonym
NOS2
4843
Homo sapiens
Primates
NOS
NOS
famplex_relations
NOS3
4846
Homo sapiens
Primates
IL-10
IL-10
ncbigene_synonym
IL10
3586
Homo sapiens
Primates
IL-4
IL-4
ncbigene_synonym
IL4
3565
Homo sapiens
Primates
mast
MAST
ncbigene_synonym
SPACA9
11092
Homo sapiens
Primates
mast
MAST
ncbigene_synonym
SPG21
51324
Homo sapiens
Primates
CD4
CD4
ncbigene_symbol
CD4
920
Homo sapiens
Primates
CD6+
CD6
ncbigene_symbol
CD6
923
Homo sapiens
Primates
STAT1
STAT1
ncbigene_symbol
STAT1
6772
Homo sapiens
Primates
STAT4
STAT4
ncbigene_symbol
STAT4
6775
Homo sapiens
Primates
STAT6
STAT6
ncbigene_symbol
STAT6
6778
Homo sapiens
Primates
GATA3
GATA3
ncbigene_symbol
GATA3
2625
Homo sapiens
Primates
C-MAF
C-MAF
ncbigene_synonym
MAF
4094
Homo sapiens
Primates
NFAT.
NFAT
famplex_relations
NFATC1
4772
Homo sapiens
Primates
NFAT.
NFAT
famplex_relations
NFATC2
4773
Homo sapiens
Primates
NFAT.
NFAT
famplex_relations
NFATC3
4775
Homo sapiens
Primates
NFAT.
NFAT
famplex_relations
NFATC4
4776
Homo sapiens
Primates
NFAT.
NFAT
famplex_relations
NFAT5
10725
Homo sapiens
Primates
T-bet)
TBET
ncbigene_synonym
TBX21
30009
Homo sapiens
Primates
NF-KB
NF-KB
ncbigene_synonym
NFKB1
4790
Homo sapiens
Primates
Th
TH
ncbigene_symbol
TH
7054
Homo sapiens
Primates
IL-5||IL-10
IL-5
ncbigene_synonym
IL5
3567
Homo sapiens
Primates
IL-2|IL-13IL-4IL-5||IL-10
IL-2
ncbigene_synonym
IL2
3558
Homo sapiens
Primates
IL-13
IL-13
ncbigene_synonym
IL13
3596
Homo sapiens
Primates
CD8+
CD8
ncbigene_synonym
CD8A
925
Homo sapiens
Primates
CD8+
CD8
famplex_relations
CD8B
926
Homo sapiens
Primates
CD25+
CD25
ncbigene_synonym
IL2RA
3559
Homo sapiens
Primates
CD25+
CD25
ncbigene_synonym
ISG20
3669
Homo sapiens
Primates
TOR
TOR
ncbigene_synonym
RORC
6097
Homo sapiens
Primates
pin
PIN
ncbigene_synonym
DYNLL1
8655
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
Hsp70
HSP70
ncbigene_synonym
hsp70.3
30671
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
Hsp70
HSP70
ncbigene_synonym
hspa8l
387608
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
Hsp70
HSP70
ncbigene_synonym
hsp70l
560210
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
Hsp70
HSP70
ncbigene_synonym
hsp70.1
100126123
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
LTA.
LTA
ncbigene_symbol
lta
554305
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
TLR2,
TLR2
ncbigene_symbol
tlr2
403125
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
TLR3,
TLR3
ncbigene_symbol
tlr3
403126
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
TLR7,
TLR7
ncbigene_symbol
tlr7
100534776
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
receptors,
RECEPTOR
ncbigene_synonym
kita
30256
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
receptors,
RECEPTOR
ncbigene_synonym
ngfra
100535003
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
APCS
APCS
ncbigene_symbol
apcs
792467
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
TIRAP
TIRAP
ncbigene_symbol
tirap
403148
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
MyD88
MYD88
ncbigene_symbol
myd88
403145
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
Croвs-
CROS
ncbigene_synonym
ros1
245951
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
IRF3
IRF3
ncbigene_symbol
irf3
564854
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
IL6
IL6
ncbigene_symbol
il6
100885851
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
TNF
TNF
ncbigene_synonym
tnfrsfa
114461
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
TNF
TNF
ncbigene_synonym
tnfb
554167
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
NOS
NOS
ncbigene_synonym
nos1
60658
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
IL-10
IL10
ncbigene_symbol
il10
553957
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
IL-4
IL-4
ncbigene_synonym
il13
794053
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
IL-4
IL-4
ncbigene_synonym
il4
100188894
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
NKT,
NKT
ncbigene_synonym
eda
798740
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
CD4
CD4
ncbigene_synonym
ighv1-1
378753
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
CD4
CD4
ncbigene_synonym
cd4-1
799982
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
STAT1
STAT1
ncbigene_synonym
stat1a
30768
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
STAT1
STAT1
ncbigene_synonym
stat1b
368481
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
STAT1
STAT1
ncbigene_synonym
stat4
368519
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
STAT6
STAT6
ncbigene_symbol
stat6
337413
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
GATA3
GATA3
ncbigene_symbol
gata3
30458
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
C-MAF
C-MAF
ncbigene_synonym
mafa
114467
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
Th
TH
ncbigene_symbol
th
30384
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
IFN
IFN
ncbigene_synonym
ifnphi1
360134
Danio rerio
Vertebrates
TOR
TOR
ncbigene_synonym
mtor
324254
Disease mentions
Word
Match
MeSH
Name
DOID