Zebrafish Studies on TGFB Signaling and Pharyngeal Arch Patterning
Summary of Zebrafish Studies on TGF-β Signaling and Pharyngeal Arch Patterning. (A) During the early stages of pharyngeal arch (PA) patterning (18–20 hpf), a ventral source of BMP activates Endothelin (Edn) signaling, which induces the expression of ventral-promoting transcription factors in the PAs (dlx5a/6a, hand2). BMP signaling also directly induced the expression of hand2 in the ventral PAs. Notch signaling (via jag1b) specifies the dorsal domain. There is also evidence that BMP signaling regulates the formation of the trabeculae in the maxillary domain (M) during this period, however how this is achieved in zebrafish in unclear. BMP is opposed by TGF-β signaling during this period, and the scaffolding protein Wdr68 permits BMP signaling by sequestering Smad2/3 and thereby inhibiting TGF-β signaling. In later stages of PA patterning (24 hpf onwards), the BMP (induced by Wnt signling) and Edn pathways act independently: BMP signaling activates the expression of ventral (hand2) and intermediate-ventral (msx1a) genes, whereas Edn induces the expression of intermediate identity specifiers (dlx3b/5a/6a, nkx3.2). Dorsal Notch signaling induces the expression of grem2, which inhibits BMP signaling and restricts hand2/msx1a to the ventral-most region of the arches. In turn, BMP signaling restricts the expression of grem2 to the dorsal region of each arch, creating distinct dorsal, intermediate, and ventral domains of gene expression. During this stage, BMP (together with Hedgehog signaling) also induces the expression of gata3 in the maxillary domain (B) The gene expression domains generated in (A) result in differential domains of prrx1 and barx1 expression, with barx1 being expressed in the intermediate domain and prrx1 being expressed in the dorsal and ventral domains (left). This, in turn, results in heterochronic onsets of chondrogenesis, where barx1+ cells initiate chondrogenesis earlier than prrx1+ cells. This heterochrony, in part, dictates the shape/identity of the resulting skeletal elements. The spatial gene expression domains in the PAs also create differential regions of fox gene expression, which dictate whether a cell will undergo osteogenesis or chondrogenesis; sox9a+/fox-regions will initiate an osteogenic gene expression program, whereas sox9a+/fox + cells will initiate a chondrogenic program (right). All images are oriented with anterior facing left
Publication
Transforming growth factor beta signaling and craniofacial development: modeling human diseases in zebrafish (2024) Sabrina C. Fox, et al. Front Cell Dev Biol. 2024;12(NA). Figure: F4.| Organism | Group | Word | Match | Source | NCBI Symbol | NCBI ID |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Homo sapiens | Primates | PA1 | PA1 | ncbigene_synonym | PAGR1 | 79447 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Notch | NOTCH | famplex_relations | NOTCH1 | 4851 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Notch | NOTCH | famplex_relations | NOTCH2 | 4853 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Notch | NOTCH | famplex_relations | NOTCH3 | 4854 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Notch | NOTCH | famplex_relations | NOTCH4 | 4855 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | hand2 | HAND2 | ncbigene_symbol | HAND2 | 9464 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | BMP1 | 649 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | BMP2 | 650 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | BMP3 | 651 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | BMP4 | 652 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | BMP5 | 653 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | BMP6 | 654 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | BMP7 | 655 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | BMP8A | 353500 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | BMP8B | 656 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | BMP10 | 27302 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | BMP15 | 9210 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | GDF1 | 2657 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | GDF2 | 2658 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | GDF3 | 9573 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | GDF5 | 8200 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | GDF6 | 392255 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | BMP | BMP | famplex_relations | GDF7 | 151449 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Edn | EDN | ncbigene_synonym | RNASE2 | 6036 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Edn | EDN | famplex_relations | EDN1 | 1906 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Edn | EDN | famplex_relations | EDN2 | 1907 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Edn | EDN | famplex_relations | EDN3 | 1908 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | gata3 | GATA3 | ncbigene_symbol | GATA3 | 2625 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wdr68 | WDR68 | ncbigene_synonym | DCAF7 | 10238 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | TGF-B | TGFB | ncbigene_synonym | TGFB1 | 7040 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | TGF-B | TGFB | famplex_relations | TGFB2 | 7042 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | TGF-B | TGFB | famplex_relations | TGFB3 | 7043 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT1 | 7471 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT2 | 7472 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT2B | 7482 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT3 | 7473 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT3A | 89780 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT4 | 54361 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT6 | 7475 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT7A | 7476 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT7B | 7477 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT8A | 7478 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT8B | 7479 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT9A | 7483 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT9B | 7484 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT10A | 80326 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT10B | 7480 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT11 | 7481 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT16 | 51384 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT5A | 7474 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | Wnt | WNT | famplex_relations | WNT5B | 81029 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | grem2 | GREM2 | ncbigene_symbol | GREM2 | 64388 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | dlx3b/5a/6a,nkx3.2,etc. | NKX3.2 | ncbigene_synonym | NKX3-2 | 579 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | prrx1+ | PRRX1 | ncbigene_symbol | PRRX1 | 5396 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | barx1+ | BARX1 | ncbigene_symbol | BARX1 | 56033 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXG1 | 2290 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXH1 | 8928 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXM1 | 2305 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXQ1 | 94234 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXS1 | 2307 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXA1 | 3169 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXA2 | 3170 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXA3 | 3171 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXB1 | 27023 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXB2 | 442425 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXC1 | 2296 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXC2 | 2303 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXD1 | 2297 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXD2 | 2306 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXD3 | 27022 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXD4 | 2298 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXE1 | 2304 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXE3 | 2301 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXF1 | 2294 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXF2 | 2295 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXI1 | 2299 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXI2 | 399823 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXI3 | 344167 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXJ1 | 2302 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXJ2 | 55810 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXJ3 | 22887 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXK1 | 221937 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXK2 | 3607 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXL1 | 2300 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXL2 | 668 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXN1 | 8456 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXN2 | 3344 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXN3 | 1112 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXN4 | 121643 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXO1 | 2308 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXO3 | 2309 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXO4 | 4303 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXO6 | 100132074 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXP1 | 27086 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXP2 | 93986 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXP3 | 50943 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXP4 | 116113 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXR1 | 283150 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXR2 | 139628 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXD4L1 | 200350 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXD4L3 | 286380 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXD4L4 | 349334 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXD4L5 | 653427 |
| Homo sapiens | Primates | sox9a+/fox+ | FOX | famplex_relations | FOXD4L6 | 653404 |
| Word | Match | MeSH | Name | ChEBI |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BMP | BMP | chebi:60815 | ||
| BMP | BMP | chebi:60815 | ||
| BMP | BMP | chebi:60815 |
Disease mentions
| Word | Match | MeSH | Name | DOID |
|---|